| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Dick Mueller MINN1st | PIN 4:45 | |
| Donald Reece OKLA2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Pat McCarron UNI3rd | DEC 3-2 | John Lee HARV4th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Pat McCarron UNI | DEC | Ted Bredehoft Cornell College |
| John Lee HARV | DEC 5-0 | Al Crancer Arkansas State |
| Semifinal | ||
| Donald Reece OKLA | DEC 3-0 | Pat McCarron UNI |
| Dick Mueller MINN | DEC 7-1 | John Lee HARV |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Al Crancer Arkansas State | DEC 9-4 | Bob Mancuso Kansas State |
| Ted Bredehoft Cornell College | DEC 4-3 | Joe Lobaugh OKST |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Donald Reece OKLA | PIN 5:34 | Bob Mancuso Kansas State |
| Pat McCarron UNI | DEC 5-4 | Jack Herschend NW |
| John Lee HARV | DEC 4-2 | Richard Hockley WYO |
| Dick Mueller MINN | DEC 5-2 | Al Crancer Arkansas State |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Donald Reece OKLA | PIN 8:45 | Ted Bredehoft Cornell College |
| Jack Herschend NW | DEC 6-4 | Alex McCord LEH |
| Bob Mancuso Kansas State | DEC 6-0 | Rex Boda COR |
| Richard Hockley WYO | DEC 6-4 | Dick Gibson WSU |
| Dick Mueller MINN | DEC 3-0 | Joe Lobaugh OKST |
| Pat McCarron UNI | DEC 4-2 | Paul Boyko Toledo |
| John Lee HARV | DEC 4-0 | Glenn Flegal MVILLE |
| Al Crancer Arkansas State | DEC 8-1 | Arnold Wilson BYU |
| Pigtail | ||
| Rex Boda COR | DEC | Yukio Matsumoto ILL |
| Richard Hockley WYO | DEC 4-3 | Donald Stubblebine Springfield College |
| Al Crancer Arkansas State | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Bob Homan PSU |
| Pat McCarron UNI | DEC 4-2 | Bob Karns ARMY |