| PIN 5:10 |
| Con Gerdes ISU |
| Gene White OKLA | PIN 1:24 | Dan Segura Cornell College |
| George Beresford PITT | PIN 1:28 | John Nickens Middle Tennessee |
| Ahmet Senol PUR | PIN 3:49 | Bob Marshall Colorado State University |
| Ted Weaver Kansas State | PIN 8:50 | Jule Moravec SDSU |
| Richard Anthony IND | DEC 3-0 | Tony Soscia West Chester |
| Joe Krufka PSU | DEC 2-0 | Fred Draayer Utah |
| Royal Smith Colorado College | DEC 6-0 | Dave Gallaher LEH |