| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| George Goodner OKLA1st | DEC 4-3 | |
| Jack Stanbro Ithaca College2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Paul Eckley Waynesburg University3rd | MAJ DEC 10-1 | Gordon Trapp IOWA4th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Gordon Trapp IOWA | DEC 4-0 | Dick Sherrill YALE |
| Paul Eckley Waynesburg University | DEC 6-1 | Art Giorgini BRWN |
| Semifinal | ||
| George Goodner OKLA | DEC 11-5 | Paul Eckley Waynesburg University |
| Jack Stanbro Ithaca College | DEC 6-2 | Gordon Trapp IOWA |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Art Giorgini BRWN | DEC 4-4 | John Trojan PSU |
| Dick Sherrill YALE | FORFEIT | Hank Poniatowski MD |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Gordon Trapp IOWA | DEC 3-3 | Fred Olm MICH |
| George Goodner OKLA | PIN 8:41 | Art Giorgini BRWN |
| Paul Eckley Waynesburg University | PIN 7:22 | Jerald Williams OKST |
| Jack Stanbro Ithaca College | DEC 9-2 | Dick Sherrill YALE |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Jack Stanbro Ithaca College | PIN 7:54 | Hank Poniatowski MD |
| Dick Sherrill YALE | DEC 7-6 | Dick Kohlhafer Baltimore |
| George Goodner OKLA | DEC 5-0 | John Trojan PSU |
| Fred Olm MICH | DEC 6-1 | Don Cory RU |
| Gordon Trapp IOWA | DEC 2-1 | Dick Keeler Long Beach State |
| Art Giorgini BRWN | DEC 10-7 | Charlie Moore LEH |
| Paul Eckley Waynesburg University | MAJ DEC 11-3 | Howard Colling WYO |
| Jerald Williams OKST | DEC 10-5 | Thomas Hall PITT |
| Pigtail | ||
| Gordon Trapp IOWA | PIN 7:29 | Bob Smith St. Lawrence |
| Charlie Moore LEH | DEC 9-4 | Mario DeStefano Springfield College |