| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Tyler McCormick MIZZ | PIN 3:52 | Christian Staylor ODU |
| Nick Gallick ISU | PIN 2:41 | Adam Frey COR |
| Jake Strayer PSU | PIN 6:19 | Lou Ruggirello HOF |
| Darrel Vasquez POLY | PIN 4:40 | Cory Vombaur WYO |
| Mack Reiter MINN | PIN 5:36 | Rick Donald BLOOM |
| Zach Tanelli WIS | DEC 7-4 | Drew Headlee PITT |
| Andrae Hernandez IND | DEC 2-0 | Mark Budd BUFF |
| Matt Valenti PENN | DEC 6-2 | Bobby Pfennigs ORST |
| Mario Galanakis IOWA | MAJ DEC 12-1 | Conor Beebe CMU |
| Coleman Scott OKST | MAJ DEC 11-1 | Omar Gaitan UCD |
| David Marble BUCK | DEC 14-7 | Tyler Dillashaw CSUF |
| Robbie Preston HARV | DEC 6-3 | T.J. Enright OSU |
| Nick Simmons MSU | MAJ DEC 13-2 | Danny Mitcheff KENT |
| Jimmy Kennedy ILL | DEC 7-4 | Seth Ciasulli LEH |
| Matt Keller CHAT | DEC 9-6 | Kyle Anson UNI |
| Joe Baker NAVY | DEC 5-1 | Evan Sola UNC |