| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Bubba Gritter CMU | PIN 4:18 | Nathan Thobaden ARMY |
| Jared Rosholt OKST | PIN 2:59 | Trey McLean PENN |
| Ed Prendergast NAVY | PIN 5:19 | Jon May NEB |
| Mike Spaid BLOOM | PIN 2:06 | Levon Mock BRWN |
| Zach Sheaffer PITT | PIN 4:11 | Nick Smith BSU |
| J.D. Bergman OSU | PIN 0:27 | Patrick Walker LIB |
| Mark Ellis MIZZ | DEC 5-4 | John Wise ILL |
| Kyle Massey WIS | DEC 3-1 | Rashard Goff Cleveland State University |
| Dustin Fox NW | TF 17-0 | Ryan Flores COLU |
| Josh Wine VMI | DEC 3-0 | Charlie Alexander UO |
| Matt Fields IOWA | DEC 7-3 | Reece Hopkin UNCO |
| Dustin Rogers WVU | DEC 4-2 | Andy Totusek ODU |
| Jermail Porter KENT | DEC 8-6 | Ben Berhow MINN |
| Nate Everhart IND | DEC 3-1 | Ed Bordas RIDER |
| David Zabriskie ISU | DEC 10-3 | Mitch Monteiro CSUB |
| Joe Fendone EDIN | DEC 10-5 | Travis Gardner ORST |