| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 16 | ||
| Luke Lilledahl PSU | — | Blake West NIU |
| Sheldon Seymour LEH | — | Caleb Smith NEB |
| Dean Peterson RU | PIN 5:42 | Richard Figueroa II ASU |
| Jett Strickenberger WVU | — | Nicolar Rivera WIS |
| Matt Ramos PUR | — | Jacob Moran IND |
| Vincent Robinson NCST | DEC 6-4 | Marc-Anthony McGowan PRIN |
| Eddie Ventresca VT | DEC 6-3 | Spencer Moore UNC |
| Troy Spratley OKST | DEC 2-1 | Stevo Poulin UNC |