| Consi 16 #2 |
| Coleman Gracey ARMY | TF 16-0 | John Fitzsimmons NYU |
| Joshua Powell SUNY Brockport | MAJ DEC 9-0 | Jerrell White Jamestown Community College |
| Chris Nevinger Niagara County Community College | DEC 10-6 | Jake Walker US Merchant Marine Academy |
| Chandler Smith ARMY | DEC 9-5 | Adam DeJesus Nassau Community College |
| Kyzen Smith NYU | DEC 8-6 | Xander Coburn US Merchant Marine Academy |
| Brian Vutianitis SUNY-Cortland | PIN | Aram Soukiasian Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Rrok Ndokaj BUFF | PIN | Amon Gervais SUNY Sullivan |
| Ibrahim Simreen Westchester Community College | PIN | Shaun Holliday Stony Brook Wrestling Club |
| James Shreck SUNY Brockport | MAJ DEC 8-0 | James Papin NYU |
| Jake Buczewski Ithaca College | TF 22-7 | Ryan Ford Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute |
| Andrew Werther Oneonta State | PIN | Daniel Tammaro SUNY Cortland Wrestling Club |
| Troy Taylor USMA Prep School | PIN | Conner Brown Rochester Institute of Technology |
