| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Round of 32 | ||
| Jarrod King EDIN | TF 16-0 | Eric Gobin ARMY |
| Joey Granata CSUB | DEC 14-8 | Justin Guthrie Unattached |
| Stephen Burak PENN | PIN 2:17 | Andy Lowy PRIN |
| Obie Simpson KENT | DEC 12-9 | Julian Colon Unattached |
| Rick Schmelyun BLOOM | TF 17-0 | Mason Bailey NAVY |
| Kyle Kiss UNC | DEC 7-6 | Kyle Blevins APP |
| Kevin Christensen OHIO | DEC 6-2 | Neil McGuire Unattached |
| Paul Young IND | PIN 5:55 | Brock Gutches Unattached |
| Chris Brown ODU | MAJ DEC 8-0 | Aaron Hynes MICH |
| Michael Chaires UVA | DEC 6-1 | Steve Wilson OHIO |
| Thomas Timothy PENN | MAJ DEC 15-2 | Kevin Dufresne LHU |
| Paul Gillespie HOF | DEC 4-1 | Ray Ward NCST |
| Justin Kerber COR | DEC 11-4 | Mike Dessino BLOOM |
| Frankie McLaughlin IV GMU | DEC 9-5 | Edwin Hojilla UNCG |
| Robby Neill NAVY | DEC 5-3 | Ben Wales DUKE |
| Dustin Schlatter MINN | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Kyle Czarnecki Boston University |