| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Consi Pigtail | ||
| Travis Berridge POLY | PIN | Dominic Lampe CHAT |
| Jordan Wohlfert CMU | TF 16-1 | Nathan Wynkoop Cleveland State University |
| Jason Carr CIT | FORFEIT | John Keck NAVY |
| Garrett Peppelman UVA | TF 16-0 | Dean Vettese MSU |
| Drew Barnes MSU | DEFAULT | Dillon Artigliere COR |
| Tyler Kinn UNCO | PIN | Zachary Appleby CIT |
| Austin Wilding ARMY | PIN | Chaz Polson WYO |
| Kyle Pope WYO | TF 16-1 | Daniel Smith CIT |