| Cons. Round 2 |
| Blake Allen Underdog Wrestling Club | DEC 6-1 | Ryan Budd Titan Wrestling Club |
| Andy Johnson Herbie Husker | DEC 4-1 | Neal Martin Mountaineer Wrestling Club |
| Brandon Perkins Orange Crush Wrestling Club | DEC 6-2 | Troy Goodban Dave Schultz WC |
| Andy Geving Lion Wrestling Club | DEC 1-0 | Brent Fiorito Cavalier Wrestling Club |
| Cody Harrington | PIN | Chris Estep Golden Pride Wrestling Club |
| Brett Nelson Bearcats | DEC 2-0 | Derek Caldwell Mat-Town USA |
| Calvin DeVault Embry-Riddle Wrestling Club | TF 7-0 | George Mann Bison Wrestling Club |
| Marcus Effner | DEC 1-0 | Cody Midlam |
| Cory Nelson Sunkist Kids Wrestling Club | DEC 6-0 | Landis Wright Mat-Town USA |
| Jack Decker | DEC 5-1 | Jacob Ison Bobcat Wrestling Club |
| Cody Waters Cliff Keen Wrestling Club | PIN | Clancy Stockton Sunkist Kids Wrestling Club |
| Tony Bradberry Ashland University | DEC 6-2 | Nick Detweiler Naval Academy Mat Club |
