| Nov 13 | Jonathan Kaloust Bearcat Open Pigtail | Ryan Dunphy | Dec 6-4 | 1-0 |
| Nov 13 | Jonathan Kaloust Bearcat Open Quarterfinal | Luke Vaith | Inj Def 1:12 | 2-0 |
| Nov 13 | Jonathan Kaloust Bearcat Open Semifinal | Mike Nevinger | Dec 4-0 | 2-1 |
| Nov 13 | Jonathan Kaloust Bearcat Open Consi Semi | Jimmy Kirchner | Maj Dec 10-2 | 2-2 |
| Nov 13 | Jonathan Kaloust Bearcat Open 3rd Place3rd | — | Dec 2-0 | 3-2 |
| Nov 13 | Jonathan Kaloust Bearcat Open True Third | Jimmy Kirchner | Dec 8-5 | 4-2 |
| Nov 18 | vs. Wisconsin | Tom Glen | Dec 8-4 | 5-2 |
| Nov 18 | @ Rider | Jimmy Kirchner | Dec 6-3 | 5-3 |
| Nov 20 | Keystone Classic Round of 16 | Uditinder Thakur | Pin 2:02 | 6-3 |
| Nov 20 | Keystone Classic Quarterfinal | Colin Shober | Dec 3-1 | 7-3 |
| Nov 20 | Keystone Classic Semifinal | Matthew Mariacher | Dec 10-4 | 7-4 |
| Nov 20 | Keystone Classic Consi Semi | Pasquale Greco | Pin 3:52 | 8-4 |
| Nov 20 | Keystone Classic 3rd Place3rd | Mike Kessler | Dec 5-0 | 9-4 |
| Dec 3 | vs. Old Dominion | Justin LaValle | Dec 10-8 | 10-4 |
| Dec 3 | @ Binghamton | Mike Sardo | Pin 1:15 | 11-4 |
| Dec 10 | vs. Rutgers | Billy Ashnault | Dec 5-3 | 11-5 |
| Dec 17 | vs. Sacred Heart | Robert O'Neill | Pin 2:28 | 12-5 |
| Dec 17 | vs. Central Michigan | Scott Mattingly | Dec 7-1 | 13-5 |
| Dec 17 | @ Bucknell | Derrik Russell | Dec 5-3 | 13-6 |
| Dec 29 | Midlands Championships Round of 32 | Dalton Kelley | Dec 7-4 | 14-6 |
| Dec 29 | Midlands Championships Round of 16 | Matthew Mariacher | Dec 6-3 | 15-6 |
| Dec 29 | Midlands Championships Quarterfinal | Brandon Nelsen | Dec 3-0 | 16-6 |
| Dec 29 | Midlands Championships Semifinal | Montell Marion | Dec 3-2 | 16-7 |
| Dec 29 | Midlands Championships 3rd Place3rd | Zach Neibert | Dec 5-4 | 17-7 |
| Jan 7 | @ Davidson | Kevin Birmingham | Pin 1:27 | 18-7 |
| Jan 7 | @ Virginia Military Institute | Zeb Stewart | Maj Dec 10-2 | 19-7 |
| Jan 13 | vs. Millersville | Aaron Trimpey | TF 5:44 | 20-7 |
| Jan 14 | @ Cornell | Mike Nevinger | Dec W | 21-7 |
| Feb 3 | @ Boston | B.J. Suitor | Pin 4:15 | 22-7 |
| Feb 4 | @ Harvard | Shay Warren | Dec 8-3 | 23-7 |
| Feb 10 | @ Columbia | Matt Bystol | Dec 6-0 | 24-7 |
| Feb 12 | @ Franklin & Marshall | Richard Durso | Dec 8-2 | 25-7 |
| Feb 18 | vs. Pennsylvania | Zack Kemmerer | Dec 3-1 | 25-8 |
| Feb 18 | @ Lehigh | Steve Dutton | Default 4:48 | 25-9 |
| Mar 3 | EIWA Tournament Round of 32 | Casey Smith | Dec 3-2 | 26-9 |
| Mar 3 | EIWA Tournament Round of 16 | Matthew Mariacher | Dec 9-3 | 26-10 |
| Mar 3 | EIWA Tournament Consi 8 #2 | Zachary Tanenbaum | Forfeit L | 26-11 |
| Mar 15 | 2012 NCAA Championships Round of 32 | Tyler Small | Dec 6-2 | 26-12 |
| Mar 15 | 2012 NCAA Championships Consi 16 #1 | Evan Henderson | Dec 9-5 | 27-12 |
| Mar 15 | 2012 NCAA Championships Consi 16 #2 | Mike Nevinger | Pin L | 27-13 |
| Season Total | 9 Bonus | 27-13 |
