| Nov 15 | Jonathan Kaloust Bearcat Open Round of 32 | Eric Ekstrom | F 4:40 | 1-0 |
| Nov 15 | Jonathan Kaloust Bearcat Open Round of 16 | Scott Hunter | F 6:59 | 2-0 |
| Nov 15 | Jonathan Kaloust Bearcat Open Quarterfinal | Rick Schmelyun | Maj Dec 10-0 | 3-0 |
| Nov 15 | Jonathan Kaloust Bearcat Open Final1st | Ryan McGarity | F 2:15 | 4-0 |
| Nov 21 | vs. Penn State | Mark Friend | Dec 7-2 | 5-0 |
| Nov 22 | Body Bar Invitational Round of 32 | Brad Clark | Pin 1:28 | 6-0 |
| Nov 22 | Body Bar Invitational Round of 16 | Michael Gorman | Pin 2:23 | 7-0 |
| Nov 22 | Body Bar Invitational Quarterfinal | Ryan Black | Pin 4:41 | 8-0 |
| Nov 22 | Body Bar Invitational Semifinal | Kurt Swartz | Maj Dec 16-6 | 9-0 |
| Nov 22 | Body Bar Invitational Final1st | Rick Schmelyun | Maj Dec 12-4 | 10-0 |
| Dec 5 | Cliff Keen Las Vegas Invitational Round of 32 | Justin Zeerip | Dec 6-1 | 11-0 |
| Dec 5 | Cliff Keen Las Vegas Invitational Round of 16 | Joe Barczak | Dec 12-5 | 12-0 |
| Dec 5 | Cliff Keen Las Vegas Invitational Quarterfinal | Andrew Howe | Dec 6-2 | 13-0 |
| Dec 5 | Cliff Keen Las Vegas Invitational Semifinal | Andrew Rendos | Dec 8-1 | 14-0 |
| Dec 5 | Cliff Keen Las Vegas Invitational Final1st | Colt Sponseller | Maj Dec 11-3 | 15-0 |
| Dec 30 | Southern Scuffle Round of 32 | Joey Granata | Maj Dec 17-4 | 16-0 |
| Dec 30 | Southern Scuffle Round of 16 | Jeff Jacobs | Maj Dec 12-4 | 17-0 |
| Dec 30 | Southern Scuffle Quarterfinal | Kyle Kiss | Pin 2:55 | 18-0 |
| Dec 30 | Southern Scuffle Semifinal | Matt Epperly | Maj Dec 13-5 | 19-0 |
| Dec 30 | Southern Scuffle Final1st | Jarrod King | Dec 3-2 | 20-0 |
| Jan 10 | vs. Ohio State | Colt Sponseller | Dec 3-1 | 21-0 |
| Jan 10 | vs. Michigan | Justin Zeerip | Dec 5-1 | 22-0 |
| Jan 11 | vs. Iowa State | Jonathan Reader | Dec 6-5 | 23-0 |
| Jan 11 | vs. Iowa | Ryan Morningstar | Dec 3-2 | 24-0 |
| Feb 8 | vs. Columbia | Eren Civan | Dec 8-7 | 25-0 |
| Feb 8 | vs. Hofstra | Ryan Patrovich | Dec 3-1 | 26-0 |
| Feb 14 | vs. Princeton | Mike Alvarez | Pin 1:17 | 27-0 |
| Feb 15 | vs. Pennsylvania | Zach Shanaman | Dec 6-4 | 28-0 |
| Feb 20 | vs. Brown | Chris Musser | Pin 2:22 | 29-0 |
| Feb 21 | vs. Harvard | Michael Sadler | Pin 1:50 | 30-0 |
| Mar 7 | EIWA Tournament Round of 16 | Andrew Coles | Dec 12-5 | 31-0 |
| Mar 7 | EIWA Tournament Quarterfinal | Thad Frick | Pin 6:25 | 32-0 |
| Mar 7 | EIWA Tournament Semifinal | Matt Pletcher | Pin 2:39 | 33-0 |
| Mar 7 | EIWA Tournament Final1st | Andrew Rendos | Dec 5-3 | 34-0 |
| Mar 19 | 2009 NCAA Championships Round of 32 | Ryan Patrovich | Dec 5-3 | 34-1 |
| Mar 19 | 2009 NCAA Championships Consi 16 #1 | Luke Manuel | Dec 3-1 | 34-2 |
| Season Total | 16 Bonus | 34-2 |
