| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Howell Scobey LEH1st | DEC | Gridley Barrows HARV2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Gridley Barrows HARV | DEC | Earl Gilman COR |
| John Hordines CUSE | ||
| DEC |
| Gridley Barrows HARV |
| John Hordines CUSE | DEC | Fred Davenport COLU |
| Howell Scobey LEH | DEC | John Hordines CUSE |
| Semifinal | ||
| Gridley Barrows HARV | DEC | C.J. Schmidlapp PRIN |
| John Hordines CUSE | DEC | Ray Yoder PSU |
| Howell Scobey LEH | PIN 4:20 | Earl Gilman COR |
| Henry Snowdon YALE | PIN 4:30 | Fred Davenport COLU |