| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Hardie Lewis OKLA1st | DEC | Harry Dyer University of Chicago2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Arlie Tomlinson OKST | ||
| — |
| Albert Campbell ILL |
| Arlie Tomlinson OKST | — | Richard Cole ISU |
| Arlie Tomlinson OKST | — | Harry Dyer University of Chicago |
| Semifinal | ||
| Hardie Lewis OKLA | DEC | Richard Cole ISU |
| Harry Dyer University of Chicago | DEC | Robert Garrigan NW |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Hardie Lewis OKLA | DEC | Albert Campbell ILL |
| Richard Cole ISU | DEC | B.P. Sargeant Lafayette |
| Harry Dyer University of Chicago | DEC | Elmer Carpenter CUSE |
| Robert Garrigan NW | PIN 3:51 | Stelljes Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Hardie Lewis OKLA | DEC | Arlie Tomlinson OKST |
| Richard Cole ISU | DEC | Cooper MIT |
| B.P. Sargeant Lafayette | DEC | Marshall MSU |
| Elmer Carpenter CUSE | DEC | Jessup IND |
| Harry Dyer University of Chicago | — | Karl Kaiser PSU |