| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Earl McCready OKST1st | PIN 2:17 | Lloyd Burdick ILL2nd |
| Consolation | ||
| Hevt Errington Kansas State | — | Ahern CUSE |
| Hevt Errington Kansas State |
| PIN |
| Dudley Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Lloyd Burdick ILL | DEC | Hevt Errington Kansas State |
| Dudley Rochester Institute of Technology | DEC | Russ Fairall OSU |
| Semifinal | ||
| Lloyd Burdick ILL | PIN 4:06 | Russ Fairall OSU |
| Earl McCready OKST | PIN 2:05 | Hevt Errington Kansas State |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Russ Fairall OSU | DEC | Max Sonderby University of Chicago |
| Lloyd Burdick ILL | PIN 4:32 | Dudley Rochester Institute of Technology |
| Earl McCready OKST | PIN 1:56 | Ahern CUSE |
| Hevt Errington Kansas State | PIN 1:09 | Boyd Waynesburg University |