| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Gene Gibbons MSU1st | PIN 7:10 | George Graveson YALE2nd |
| Don Thomas NAVY3rd | DEC 8-5 | Ken Prihoda Minnesota State4th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Don Thomas NAVY | DEC | Clyde Dilley UNI |
| Ken Prihoda Minnesota State | DEC 6-3 | Ray Vohden RU |
| Semifinal | ||
| Gene Gibbons MSU | DEC 3-2 | Ray Vohden RU |
| George Graveson YALE | DEC 6-1 | Don Thomas NAVY |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Ken Prihoda Minnesota State | DEC 4-0 | Jack Platt LEH |
| Clyde Dilley UNI | DEC 2-0 | Floyd Gadt Toledo |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| George Graveson YALE | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Clyde Dilley UNI |
| Gene Gibbons MSU | DEC 6-3 | Jack Platt LEH |
| Don Thomas NAVY | DEC 11-7 | Joe Lemyre PSU |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Don Thomas NAVY | PIN 4:10 | Joe Butler OKLA |
| Joe Lemyre PSU | PIN 6:55 | Bill Fritzche KENT |
| Tom Titsworth OKST | MAJ DEC 11-2 | Lou Scalzo ARMY |
| Gene Gibbons MSU | DEC 5-2 | Ken Prihoda Minnesota State |
| Jack Platt LEH | DEC 7-2 | Ken Morton HOF |
| Clyde Dilley UNI | DEC 3-0 | James Mancuso Carleton |
| George Graveson YALE | MAJ DEC 9-1 | Floyd Gadt Toledo |