| WINNER | METHOD | OPPONENT |
|---|---|---|
| Finals | ||
| Brad Glass PRIN1st | DEC | Homer Barr PSU2nd |
| Medal Round | ||
| Harry Lanzi Toledo3rd |
| DEC 8-5 |
| Bill Miller OSU4th |
| Consi Semi | ||
| Harry Lanzi Toledo | PIN 3:20 | Bill Priest UNCO |
| Bill Miller OSU | DEC 5-0 | Bill Helfferich Ursinus College |
| Semifinal | ||
| Brad Glass PRIN | PIN 3:57 | Bill Priest UNCO |
| Homer Barr PSU | DEC 6-2 | Bill Miller OSU |
| Consi 4 | ||
| Harry Lanzi Toledo | PIN 1:35 | Jim Murray HOF |
| Bill Helfferich Ursinus College | PIN 3:55 | George Myers IOWA |
| Quarterfinal | ||
| Brad Glass PRIN | PIN 2:37 | Jim Murray HOF |
| Bill Miller OSU | DEC | Bill Kerslake Case-Western Reserve |
| Homer Barr PSU | MAJ DEC 12-3 | Bill Helfferich Ursinus College |
| Round of 16 | ||
| Brad Glass PRIN | DEC | Harry Lanzi Toledo |
| Bill Miller OSU | MAJ DEC 10-2 | Donald Berndt LEH |
| Homer Barr PSU | DEC 5-1 | George Myers IOWA |
| Jim Murray HOF | DEC 7-3 | Dick Sloan Carleton |
| Wilbanks Smith OKST | DEC 4-2 | Lee Wachenheim UNI |
| Bill Kerslake Case-Western Reserve | MAJ DEC 9-1 | John Lezdey RU |