| Nov 1 | Non-Conf | @ Campbell | 9–25 | 0-1 | — |
| Nov 5 | Tourn | Princeton Open | — | — | Jadwin Gymnasium · Princeton, NJ |
| Nov 11 | Non-Conf | vs. Purdue | 6–0 | 1-1 | — |
| Nov 11 | Non-Conf | @ Lock Haven | 21–9 | 2-1 | — |
| Nov 12 | Tourn | Journeymen Collegiate Classic | — | — | Freedom High School · Bethlehem, PA |
| Nov 16 | Non-Conf | vs. North Carolina State | 6–31 | 2-2 | — |
| Dec 2 | Tourn | Cougar Clash | — | — | Sam M. Vadalabene Center · Edwardsville, IL |
| Jan 1 | Tourn | Southern Scuffle | — | — | McKenzie Arena Box Office · Chattanooga, TN |
| Jan 5 | Tourn | F&M Lehman Open | — | — | F&M College · Lancaster, PA |
| Jan 14 | Conf | vs. Columbia | 25–13 | 3-2 | — |
| Jan 14 | Conf | vs. Drexel | 26–9 | 4-2 | — |
| Jan 21 | Conf | @ Binghamton | 22–11 | 5-2 | — |
| Jan 27 | Conf | @ Bucknell | 18–15 | 6-2 | — |
| Jan 28 | Tourn | Lock Haven Mat Town College Open 2 | — | — | Thomas Field House · Lock Haven, PA |
| Feb 4 | Conf | vs. Lehigh | 16–20 | 6-3 | — |
| Feb 16 | Conf | @ Naval Academy | 18–17 | 7-3 | — |
| Feb 25 | Conf | vs. American | 28–6 | 8-3 | — |
| Mar 8 | EIWA Champs | EIWA Championship | 953rd | — | Bucknell University · Lewisburg, PA |
| Mar 21 | NCAA Champs | 2024 NCAA Championships | — | — | T-Mobile Center · Kansas City, MO |
