| WRESTLER | TITLES | SEASONS | WT |
|---|---|---|---|
| Adeline Gray | 7 | 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2018, 2023 | 63, 67, 72, 75, 76 kg |
| Robby Smith | 4 | 2014, 2017, 2018 | 130 kg |
| Ben Provisor | 3 | 2017, 2022 | 82, 85 kg |
| Tyler Graff | 3 | 2008, 2010, 2017 | 57, 60 kg |
| Andrew Howe | 3 | 2010, 2012, 2013 | 74, 79 kg |
| Jake Herbert | 3 | 2008, 2010, 2011 | 84 kg |
| Justin Ruiz | 3 | 2007, 2008, 2010 | 96 kg |
| Steve Mocco | 3 | 2006, 2007, 2008 | 120 kg |
| Adrian Artsisheuskiy | 2 | 2025, 2026 | 82 kg |
| Alan Vera | 2 | 2022, 2023 | 87 kg |
| Kendrick Sanders | 2 | 2012, 2019 | 66, 82 kg |
| Dalton Roberts | 2 | 2017, 2018 | 59, 60 kg |
| RaVaughn Perkins | 2 | 2017, 2018 | 71, 72 kg |
| Jimmy Kennedy | 2 | 2013, 2017 | 60, 70 kg |
| Angel Escobedo | 2 | 2010, 2013 | 55 kg |
| Brent Metcalf | 2 | 2010, 2013 | 66 kg |
| Veronica Carlson | 2 | 2010, 2013 | 63, 67 kg |
| Jake Fisher | 2 | 2010, 2011 | 74 kg |
| Andy Hrovat | 2 | 2007, 2009 | 84, 96 kg |
| Bryce Hasseman | 2 | 2009 | 84 kg |
| Deanna Rix | 2 | 2009 | 59 kg |
| Alaina Berube | 2 | 2006, 2008 | 63 kg |
| Lindsey Durlacher | 2 | 2006, 2007 | 55 kg |
| Aden Attao | 1 | 2026 | 130 kg |
| Kenneth Crosby | 1 | 2026 | 55 kg |
| Rhett Peak | 1 | 2025 | 60 kg |
| Beka Melelashvili | 1 | 2024 | 82 kg |
| Robert Perez 111 | 1 | 2024 | 67 kg |
| David Stepanian | 1 | 2023 | 67 kg |
| Erin Golston | 1 | 2022 | 50 kg |
| Jesse Porter | 1 | 2020 | 77 kg |
| Richie Lewis | 1 | 2019 | 74 kg |
| Sarah Hildebrandt | 1 | 2018 | 53 kg |
| Cheney Haight | 1 | 2017 | 80 kg |
| G'Angelo Hancock | 1 | 2017 | 98 kg |
| Haley Augello | 1 | 2017 | 53 kg |
| Katherine Fulp-Allen | 1 | 2014 | 53 kg |
| Alli Ragan | 1 | 2013 | 59 kg |
| J.D. Bergman | 1 | 2013 | 96 kg |
| Kellen Russell | 1 | 2013 | 66 kg |
| Reece Humphrey | 1 | 2013 | — |
| Amy Whitbeck | 1 | 2010 | 51 kg |
| Helen Maroulis | 1 | 2010 | 55 kg |
| Kristie Davis | 1 | 2010 | 67 kg |
| Brandon Rupp | 1 | 2009 | 120 kg |
| Jacob Curby | 1 | 2009 | 66 kg |
| Jessica Medina | 1 | 2009 | 51 kg |
| Justin Lester | 1 | 2009 | 74 kg |
| Spenser Mango | 1 | 2009 | 55 kg |
| TC Dantzler | 1 | 2009 | 84 kg |
| Josh Churella | 1 | 2008 | 66 kg |
| Konrad Dudziak | 1 | 2008 | 96 kg |
| Sara Fulp-Allen | 1 | 2008 | 48 kg |
| Brad Vering | 1 | 2007 | 84 kg |
| Clint Wattenberg | 1 | 2007 | 84 kg |
| Mary Kelly | 1 | 2007 | 48 kg |
| Travis Lee | 1 | 2007 | 60 kg |
| Kristie Marano | 1 | 2006 | 67 kg |